×

Recent Posts

  • Hidden in Plain Sight: Trafficking in Forced Displacement Contexts_www.onendavid.com

    Hidden in Plain Sight: Trafficking in Forced Displacement Contexts

    While extinguishing and curbing the crime of tr...

SIGN IN YOUR ACCOUNT TO HAVE ACCESS TO DIFFERENT FEATURES

No apps configured. Please contact your administrator.

CREATE AN ACCOUNT FORGOT YOUR PASSWORD?

FORGOT YOUR DETAILS?

AAH, WAIT, I REMEMBER NOW!

CREATE ACCOUNT

ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT?
QUESTIONS? CALL: +256 772 184 247
  • SIGN UP
  • LOGIN
  • SUPPORT

Onen David Ongwech

Onen David Ongwech

Welcome to my site. I appreciate your time and visit.

+256 772 184 247
Email: [email protected]

Onen David Ongwech
C/o Refugee Law Project, P.O Box 33903, Kampala, Uganda

Open in Google Maps
  • Home
  • Portfolio
    • About Me
      • About Onen David Ongwech
      • Refugee Law Project
    • Projects (Ongoing & Concluded)
      • Ongoing Projects
      • Concluded Projects
    • Consultancies
      • Ambassadorial Briefings
      • Institutional Evaluations
    • SOAS Radio
      • SOAS Refugee Forum
  • Advocacy
  • Media Engagements
    • Television Features/Appearances
      • RLP Launches Innovation Centre – Ambassador
      • RLP Launches Innovation Centre – Dr Chris Dolan
      • Commemorating World Refugee Day 2019| NBSTV
      • World Environment Day 2018
      • Elimination of Sexual Violence Day 2018
      • Expounding the plights of refugees in Uganda
      • Male Rape Victims Meet in Uganda
      • Sexual Violence as a tool of subjugation
    • Online Media
      • Activists want interpreters in hospitals
      • New forms of sexual violence merge in conflict areas – Experts
      • Research can help transform lives
      • INZ reconsiders visa application from Ugandan anti-sexual violence advocate
      • A call to end torture using the law
      • Celebrations for UN Day of Torture Survivors launched
      • We Ought to Fight Dependence on Technology
      • Breaking the Spell of Silence: Collective Healing as Activism amongst Refugee Male Survivors of Sexual Violence in Uganda
      • SOAS Sanctuary Scholarships
    • Radio Podcasts
      • SOAS Refugee Forum – Episode #1: Ockenden International Prize Award
      • SOAS Refugee Forum – Episode #2: Interviews with Ockenden International Prize Winners
      • SOAS Refugee Forum – Episode #3: “Lost in Identity: The Struggle to Belong”
      • SOAS Refugee Forum – Episode #4: “The Struggle for Safety”
      • SOAS Refugee Forum – Episode #5: “A Glimpse into Uganda’s Refugee Management Policy.”
    • Other Videos
      • Onen David’s Message to the 3rd South – South Institute
      • Born Julia and Julius
      • Support the SOAS Sanctuary Scholarship Appeal #EducationBeyondBorders
  • Latest Posts
  • Resources
    • Downloads
    • Presentations
    • Resource Packs
    • Writings and Publications
      • Thesis/Dissertations
      • Press Statements/Releases
        • Day of the African Child 2018
        • Elimination of Sexual Violence Day 2018
        • World Refugee Day 2018
      • Peer Reviewed Articles
      • Book Reviews
    • Photos
      • Capacity Building
        • Military Personnel – Senior Command 20 02 12
        • Police Officials
      • General
        • Random Thoughts
      • International Days
        • UN Day Against Torture 2019
        • International Day for the Elimination of Sexual Violence in Conflict 2019
        • International Women’s Day 2020
      • Events
        • Wild Life & Nature
          • When Birds Seek Refuge on a Rainy Day
        • Strategic Review July 2019
        • Project Launch – Securing Refugee-Host Relations
        • Psycho-Medical and Legal Clinic 2019
  • e-Library
  • Photography
  • Support
  • MY CART
    No products in cart.
Support
  • Home
  • Pages – Blog Posts
  • Sexual Violence Debate
  • When should you ‘Call It What It Is’? Enabling disclosure of sexual violence by Chris Dolan and Onen David
July 2, 2022

When should you ‘Call It What It Is’? Enabling disclosure of sexual violence by Chris Dolan and Onen David

6
David Onen Ongwech
Saturday, 15 February 2020 / Published in Sexual Violence Debate

When should you ‘Call It What It Is’? Enabling disclosure of sexual violence by Chris Dolan and Onen David

Call-It-What-It-Is - onendavid.com

Hits: 203

Editor’s Note: This post was originally published by bliss, The ISS Blog on Global Development and Social Justice on February 13, 2020 at 8:04hrs.

When should you ‘Call It What It Is’? Enabling disclosure of sexual violence by Chris Dolan and Onen David

The international criminal law (ICL) system can only hear and describe a tiny fraction of what people experience, particularly when it comes to sexual violence. The ICL system not only makes it difficult for victims to disclose their experiences, but often misplaces, deprioritises and erases the sexual elements of violence under other headings such as ‘torture’ and ‘inhumane treatment’. This is what inspired ‘Call It What It Is’, a campaign designed to enable victims to freely testify in a system where sexual violence is better articulated.

Back in 2009, when the Refugee Law Project at Makerere University in Uganda ran its first-ever workshop for male refugees on the topic of sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV), a male Congolese workshop participant commented at the close of the day that ‘it has happened to all of us’, referring to having been subjected to conflict-related sexual violence. Similarly, a Somali participant reported that ‘if it happened to me, I would have to commit suicide’.

Their use of the word ‘it’, and their assumption that we (as social workers and refugee rights advocates) would somehow understand which of the many forms that ‘it’ (sexual violence) can take they had experienced, epitomises the yawning gap between people’s lived experiences, how they talk about those experiences, and definitions and the language available in legal systems intended to bring justice to victims. At present, the international criminal law (ICL) system for prosecuting perpetrators specifies only a handful of the multiple forms that sexual violence can take. The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court refers to “rape, sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced sterilization, or any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity”[1].

It is the need to specify further the forms that might be considered under the catch-all “any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity” that gave rise to the ‘Call It What It Is’ campaign, launched in 2019 by The Hague-based Women’s Ik1-1024x515nitiatives for Gender Justice. The key premise of the campaign is that, if survivors of SGBV are to get the support they need, it is imperative to call and describe a range of forms of violence as ‘sexual’. Second, and related to the first, for each victim/survivor, it is important to be able to name which of the numerous possible forms of sexual violence they have actually experienced. This is in order to allow correspondingly informed and appropriate responses that consciously sidestep the hierarchy of forms of sexual violence. Assumptions that rape is both the most important and most prevalent form of sexual violence are reflected in legal frameworks and service providers alike and are at the heart of this hierarchy.

The campaign is catalysed and coordinated by the Women’s Initiatives for Gender Justice, with varied contributions from more than 500 survivors. The collection of these was supported by dozens of organisations, including the Refugee Law Project which ran focus-group discussions. The campaign is raising the definitional bar for international criminal lawyers in general and the International Criminal Court in particular. The Civil Society Declaration developed as part of the campaign gives survivors and allies a new tool to deploy in the search for justice, calls for an end to impunity of perpetrators and an end to the inaction that is characteristic of many self-styled ‘responders’ in the fields of sexual violence.

Calling ‘it’ what it is cannot be a politically neutral process, however, and this raises particular challenges for institutions. ‘Rape’ as a ‘weapon of war’, laden as it is with a range of unevidenced assumptions about prevalence and gendered distribution of harms, is not an adequate descriptor of the complex universe of sexual harms that people, whether male, female, or gender non-conforming, experience in conflict settings. Establishing a more comprehensive understanding also demands a corresponding diversification of medical, psychosocial and legal services for the survivors and use of broader terminology to encompass ‘sexual violence [rather than only rape] as a weapon of war’.

The Refugee Law Project’s experience is that this diversification is possible. Back in 2009, no individual male refugee whom we were working with would identify himself in public as a survivor of conflict-related sexual violence. Ten years later, the male survivor support group Men of Hope was able to pull together 310 male refugee survivors in Kampala alone for the International Day for the Elimination of Sexual Violence in Conflict. Just two months earlier, their leader, Mr Aimé Moninga, addressed the UN Trust Fund for Victims of Torture in Geneva.

These successes have also taught us a lot about when not to call it what it is. The ‘When’, ‘Where’, ‘Who’ and even ‘Why’ of enabling disclosure of sexual violence—of making it possible for survivors accurately to call it what it is—has to be viewed as a complex process. Disclosure cannot be scripted or predicted. For some, the ‘When’ may be months after the incident. For others, it may take decades. For very few will it be within the 72 hours that Post-Exposure Prophylaxis demands to try and prevent the transmission of HIV.

The ‘Where’ of disclosure can also be a difficult choice: how do you balance the needs for access to support with the demands for privacy? In many refugee settlements in Uganda, for example, there are no spaces purpose-built to receive survivors needing help; meeting in a survivor’s home is rarely advisable as (s)he generally has not disclosed their exposure to SGBV to family members. Transporting a person to a supposedly neutral space, such as a hotel, carries further risks, as observers (which could include security forces or family members) are likely identify the vehicle and draw their own (sometimes dangerous) conclusions about what the survivor is doing sharing information with the institution associated with a particular vehicle.

‘Who’ should be asking such questions can be yet another conundrum when developing inclusive services for a broad spectrum of survivors. While it is often assumed that women wish to talk to women and men to men, it is rarely that simple. Ethnicity, age, prior reputation, or familiarity built through prior interactions can be even more important determinants of whether someone feels comfortable to talk to a particular person.

Last but not least, ‘Why’ would a person choose to ‘Call It What It Is’? Naming and disclosure are high-risk actions, the more so for people made vulnerable by their experiences and the context in which they seek to survive. In our work with forced migrants living in Uganda, the tangible benefits that make the biggest difference are the availability of high-quality medical referrals, treatment, and related psychosocial support. Without that, even after years of trust building, the risks that can arise from calling it what it is may continue to outweigh the benefits.

These considerations help us to see that, while for policy and law makers it is essential to start from a position of articulation, such as the Declaration, for survivors themselves, and for practitioners working to support them, calling it what it is may often be the end-point of a lengthy process.

[1] The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, Article 7.1 (g)

The ideas presented in this article were originally presented in the seminar “Call it what it is: when should we talk about conflict-related sexual violence?” at the ISS in cooperation with the Refugee Law Project.

Simple Contact Form

Share with:


  • Tweet
Tagged under: Conflict-related sexual violence, Daily Monitor, Dr Chris Dolan, Justice Rapid Response, Kim Thuy-Seelinger, Laurel Fletcher, Onen David Ongwech, Refugee Forum, Refugee Law Project, SOAS Refugee Forum, SOAS University of London, The New Vision, UN Women, UNHCR, WIGJ, Women's Initiative for Gender Justice

What you can read next

Peacekeepers as allies in tackling sexual violence in conflict
Peacekeepers as allies in tackling sexual violence in conflict
SVAgenda2019
Sexual Violence in Conflict: Advancing the Agenda?
Sexual violence: Male rape as a tool of subjugation during war

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Hidden in Plain Sight: Trafficking in Forced Displacement Contexts_www.onendavid.com

    Hidden in Plain Sight: Trafficking in Forced Displacement Contexts

    While extinguishing and curbing the crime of tr...
  • International_Day_of_Forest_www.onendavid.com

    Grow food crops or plant trees? The binary dilemma of sustainable forest production and consumption

    We should not need a reminder that 31 per cent ...
  • IWD200_Cover_Photo_www.onendavid.com

    Sustainable tomorrow without a guaranteed today? A call for renewed commitments towards gender equality in a time of existential threats. 

    Happy International Women’s Day! This year the ...
  • Julius_Okwera_www.onendavid.com

    SAVE THE DATES: South-South Institute on Sexual Violence – 2022 Webinar Series

    On behalf of the South-South Institute on Sexua...
  • Navigating the question of protection for internally displaced persons (IDPs) require significant attention to their concerns in developing sustainable solutions. In certain instances, relocation may be resisted. Such resistance may be symptomatic of certain issues that need to be addressed. With a specific focus on the Bududa residents in the Mt. Elgon region of Uganda, this Policy Brief written by Onen David Ongwech examines the issue of resistance to relocation and advocates for rethinking protection strategies.

    When communities resist relocation: rethinking strategies for protecting the displaced residents of Bududa in Uganda

    Navigating the question of protection for inter...
  • Why not mute negative energy? onendavid.com

    Why Not Mute Negative Energy? Lessons from Audio Mixers

    Let’s face it; some people are gifted and exper...
  • Igniting Women Participation in Peace Building_onendavid.com

    COVID-19 is a threat to Gender Equality. Let’s #ChooseToChallenge

    Dear Reader, Herein, I bring to you a copy of p...
  • 2020 National Learning Event Report

    “Our Parents Do Not Know” Homeschooling fatigue among refugee children during COVID-19.

    In case you missed the 2020 National Virtual Le...
  • Our-Parents-Do-Not-Know-www.onendavid.com.png

    2020 National Virtual Learning Event on Child Wellbeing

    The 2020 National Virtual Learning Event on Chi...
  • UCA 2020 Poster

    16th Annual UG Counsellors Conference [26-27 November 2020]

    Refugee Law Project, with support from the Neth...
  • Peacekeepers as allies in tackling sexual violence in conflict

    Peacekeepers as allies in tackling sexual violence in conflict

    When peacekeepers are equipped to understand, r...
  • GENIDA_onendavid.com

    Submission to UN Secretary General’s High-Level Panel on Internal Displacement

    As a former Internally Displaced Person (IDP), ...
  • Hard_and_Unbearable_www.onendavid.com

    “Hard and Unbearable”: COVID-19 Induced Challenges as told by Refugee and Host Support Group Leaders

    Since the first case of COVID-19 was detected i...
  • Participant showing his message3

    What if we responded to sexual violence in conflict as an existential threat? Statement for International Day for the Elimination of Sexual Violence in Conflict, 2020

    In the statement to mark the occasion, RLP aske...
  • Child_on_Fathers_Shoulder_onendavid.com

    Why are children being chased away from community-related awareness raising events?

    Robinson Ocira, a Project Assistant based in th...
  • Chief Guest warns public servants against torture

    NO JUSTIFICATION FOR TORTURE – Press statement for International Day in Support of Victims of Torture

    Despite the existing legal frameworks prohibiti...
  • 2020_DAC_Photo_Black_and_White_onendavid.com

    Child-friendly Justice in Unfriendly Environments? A call for practical solutions for vulnerable young people on the Day of the African Child, 2020

    Children come into contact with the justice sys...
  • Word_Refugee_Day_2020_onendavid.com

    Inactivity is Perpetration: A Press Statement on the World Refugee Day (June 20, 2020)

    For refugees, the Covid 19 pandemic is beyond a...
  • ‘Work Went Home:’ A satirical projection of teleworking.

    This piece explores the dynamics of working fro...
  • Silent_Victims_onendavid.com

    The Loud Silence: The plight of refugee male survivors of conflict-related sexual violence

    A thought-provoking blog piece written by Wokor...

Follow me on Twitter

Tweets by @ongwechd

Archives

  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • April 2021
  • January 2021
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • March 2018
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • June 2015
  • June 2014
  • January 2014
  • Home
  • Portfolio
    • About Me
    • Projects (Ongoing & Concluded)
    • Consultancies
    • SOAS Radio
  • Advocacy
  • Media Engagements
    • Television Features/Appearances
    • Online Media
    • Radio Podcasts
    • Other Videos
  • Latest Posts
  • Resources
    • Downloads
    • Presentations
    • Resource Packs
    • Writings and Publications
    • Photos
  • e-Library
  • Photography
  • Support
  • GET SOCIAL

© 2020 Onen David Ongwech. Contact Onen David Ongwech.

TOP